| First Line | Tune | Verses | Source | Tick to select |
| I am a new creation, no more in condemnation | I am a new creation | 1 | PP060 | |
| I am not skilled to understand what God has willed | Keston | 6 | HP221 | |
| I am not worthy, holy Lord | Leicester | 4 | MH758 | |
| I am so glad . . . . . that Jesus loves me | I am so glad | 4 | MH421 | |
| I am the Bread of Life | I am the Bread of Life | 5 | HP611 | |
| I am thine, O Lord; I have heard Thy voice | Draw Me Nearer | 4 | MH746 | |
| I am trusting Thee, Lord Jesus | Trust | 6 | MH521a | |
| I am trusting Thee, Lord Jesus | Bullinger | 6 | MH521b | |
| I bind unto myself today the strong name | St Patrick/Dierdre | 6 | HP695a | |
| I bind unto myself today the strong name | St Patrick/Clonmacnoise | 6 | HP695b | |
| I bow in silence at Thy feet | Erskine | 5 | MH687 | |
| I cannot tell why he, whom angels worship | Londonderry Air | 4 | HP238 | |
| I come with joy to meet my Lord | Kilmarnock | 5 | HP610a | |
| I come with joy to meet my Lord | St Botolph | 5 | HP610b | |
| I danced in the morning when the world was begun | Lord of the Dance | 4 | MX005 | |
| I greet thee, who my sure Redeemer art | Farley Castle | 5 | HP391 | |
| I hear the sound of rustling in the leaves of the trees | I hear the sound . . . | 3 | MX040 | |
| I hear Thy welcome voice that calls me, Lord | Calvary | 5 | MH351 | |
| I heard the voice of Jesus say | Vox Dilecti | 3 | HP136 | |
| I hunger and I thirst | Ibstone | 5 | HP730 | |
| I know that my Redeemer lives - What joy . . . | Torquay | 4 | HP196 | |
| I know that my Redeemer lives and ever prays | Crediton | 6 | HP731 | |
| I lift my heart to Thee, Saviour divine | Sursum Corda | 5 | MH451 | |
| I lift up mine eyes to the hills | Psalm 121 | 4 | HP498 | |
| I love to hear the story which angel voices tell | Angels' Story | 3 | MH856 | |
| I met the good Shepherd just now on the plain | St Wilfrid | 4 | MH174 | |
| I need thee every hour, most gracious Lord | I Need Thee | 4 | HP524 | |
| I saw a fair mayden sytten and sing | Lullay Myn Lyking | 4 | MX073 | |
| I sing the almighty power of God | St Saviour | 5 | HP334a | |
| I sing the almighty power of God | Montrose | 5 | HP334b | |
| I think, when I read that sweet story of old | Athens | 3 | MH865 | |
| I to the hills will lift mine eyes | Dundee | 4 | HP496 | |
| I want a principle within of jealous godly fear | St Leonard (Smart) | 5 | HP422 | |
| I want the Spir't of power within | Bickley | 5 | HP291 | |
| I will enter his gates with thanksgiving in my heart | I will enter his gates | 1 | PP077 | |
| I will magnify your name, O Lord. Hallelujah! | I will magnify your name | 4 | MX058 | |
| I will pour out my Spirit on all flesh | Whitsun Canticle | 4 | HP292 | |
| I will sing the wondrous story of the Christ | Calon Lan | 5 | HP223a | |
| I will sing the wondrous story of the Christ | Hyfrydol | 5 | HP223b | |
| I'll go in the strength of the Lord | Strength of the Lord | 3 | MX022 | |
| I'll praise my Maker while I've breath | Monmouth | 4 | HP439a | |
| I'll praise my Maker while I've breath | Dresden (Lucerne) | 4 | HP439b | |
| I'm not ashamed to own my Lord | Arden | 4 | HP677a | |
| I'm not ashamed to own my Lord | Richmond | 4 | HP677b | |
| I've found a friend; O such a friend! | Constance | 4 | MH423 | |
| If thou but suffer God to guide thee | Nicht Das Ich's Schon (Ergriffen) | 3 | HP713 | |
| Immortal Love, forever full, forever flowing free | Stracathro | 7 | HP392a | |
| Immortal Love, forever full, forever flowing free | Haresfield | 7 | HP392b | |
| Immortal, invisible, God only wise | St Denio | 5 | HP009 | |
| In Adam we have all been one | St Mary | 6 | HP420a | |
| In Adam we have all been one | St Nicholas | 6 | HP420b | |
| In all my vast concerns with thee | Wiltshire | 5 | HP072 | |
| In Christ there is no east or west | McKee | 4 | HP758a | |
| In Christ there is no east or west | Kilmarnock | 4 | HP758b | |
| In heavenly armour . . . the battle belongs to the Lord | In Heavenly Armour | 3 | PP068 | |
| In heavenly love abiding | Penlan | 3 | HP678 | |
| In loving-kindness Jesus came | He Lifted Me | 4 | MH336 | |
| In our day of thanksgiving one psalm let us offer | St Catherine's Court | 4 | HP660 | |
| In our dear Lord's garden, planted here below | Castle Eden | 6 | MH843 | |
| In the bleak midwinter | Cranham | 4 | HP107a | |
| In the bleak midwinter | In the bleak (Darke) | 4 | HP107b | |
| In the cross of Christ I glory | Love Divine | 5 | HP167a | |
| In the cross of Christ I glory | Adoration (Hunt) | 5 | HP167b | |
| In the cross of Christ I glory | All for Jesus | 5 | HP167c | |
| In the power of God's own Spirit Jesus entered Galilee | The Spain | 4 | HP317 | |
| Infant holy, Infant lowly, For his bed a cattle stall | Polish Carol | 2 | MX071 | |
| Into a world of dark, waste and disordered space | Beweley | 6 | HP290 | |
| Isn't he beautiful? | Isn't he Beautiful? | 1 | PP071 | |
| It came upon a midnight clear | Noel | 4 | HP108 | |
| It is a thing most wonderful | Herongate | 4 | HP224a | |
| It is a thing most wonderful | Brookfield (Gideon) | 4 | HP224b | |
| It is God who holds the nations in the hollow | Vision | 4 | HP404 | |
| It passeth knowledge, that dear love of thine | It Passeth Knowledge | 5 | HP526 | |
| It's me, it's me, O Lord, standing in the need of prayer | Standing in the need | 4 | MX009 | |
